B

Board Games

— Cardboard, dice, and good company
121 members Created Mar 2026

Catan: expectations vs reality

Orleans is the bag-building game that convinced me bag-building deserves its own category separate from deck building. Drawing workers from a bag creates a probability puzzle that deck building's shuffle-and-draw cannot replicate. You know your bag composition exactly; you do not know what you will draw this turn. The tension is perfectly calibrated.

The trade mechanic creates genuine player interaction without direct conflict — you want goods that others are also collecting, which creates a market competition that feels different from card drafting. The building track creates a long-term development arc that rewards early efficiency.

For groups that enjoy Dominion and want a worker-placement adjacent experience, Orleans is the recommendation. The bag manipulation — adding and removing workers of specific types — creates a planning depth that pure deck building lacks.

29

Report thread

Why are you reporting this thread?

Restore the redacted content?

This will make it visible to everyone again. The clear action is logged in the mod log.