B

Book Club

— Reading together, one book at a time
77 members Created May 2026

TV adaptations that are better than their source books — a ranked list

Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose is a detective novel set in a medieval Italian monastery, narrated by a young novice, featuring a mystery involving a series of deaths and a locked library. It is also a novel about the history of ideas, the nature of signs, the transmission of classical texts, and the politics of institutional religion in the fourteenth century. Both things are true simultaneously.

Eco believed that genre fiction could be a vehicle for serious intellectual content without apology. He proved it. The detective plot is genuinely engaging — I still remember the solution and the mechanism — while the surrounding apparatus of historical detail creates something that reads more like inhabited research than historical fiction.

The novel does something I've found in almost no other detective fiction: it makes the act of reading itself the subject. The library at the center is dangerous not just as a location but as a concept. The book that cannot be read is the book that kills.

24

Report thread

Why are you reporting this thread?

Restore the redacted content?

This will make it visible to everyone again. The clear action is logged in the mod log.