Cate Blanchett in Notes on a Scandal deserved more awards conversation
On how Christopher Nolan uses non-linear structure and whether the technique serves his films.
Nolan's non-linear storytelling is his most celebrated and most contested formal characteristic. Memento uses reverse chronology to trap the viewer inside the protagonist's condition. The Prestige uses a structure where the film's dual timelines are the film's subject. Dunkirk uses three simultaneous timelines at different temporal scales.
In Memento, the non-linearity earns its complexity: the viewer's experience of confusion mirrors the protagonist's experience of memory loss, and the reversal of chronology is not a puzzle mechanism but an experiential argument.
In The Prestige, the double timeline is about doubling and deception — the structure is the metaphor.
In Dunkirk, the temporal multiplicity is about the relativity of time under extreme stress: different people on different timescales experiencing the same event at different rates.
The criticism of Nolan's non-linearity is that it sometimes prioritizes the formal effect over the emotional investment. Tenet, his most extreme structural experiment, is a film where following the time mechanics requires so much cognitive attention that the characters become ciphers. The formal achievement is real and the emotional engagement is thin.